Nie Z.-H.,Xingtai peoples hospitel |
Kong F.-L.,Xingtai peoples hospitel |
Shen Y.,Hebei Medical University |
Liu Z.-P.,Xingtai peoples hospitel |
And 2 more authors.
Life Science Journal | Year: 2013
Objective: To evaluate the clinical effect for postoperative of BRYAN cervical disc replacement and anterior cervical discectomy and fusion(ACDF) by Meta-analysis. Method: We searched Medline, PubMed, EMBASE,CBM, CNKI, et al. and searched manually the 7 relevant Chinese orthopedic journals for Articles Digital to clinical research of BRYAN cervical disc replacement and ACDF. Meta -analysis and forest plots were conducted with RevMan software. Results: There are 9 articles included 935 patients (452 patients for BRYAN cervical dis replacement, 483 patients for ACDF) in our Meta-analysis. At of 12 months and (or) 24 months after operation ROM, NDI, VAS, JOA, et al no statistically significant differences. Conclusion: Our results indicate that Bryan cervical disc replacement is superior than ACDF in maintaining the ROM. But the two operation program no difference the clinical effect.